fix(tool-search): reliably hide deferred MCP schemas by removing the ContextVar (closures + graph state) (#3342)

* feat(tool-search): add hash-scoped promoted state to ThreadState

* feat(tool-search): add immutable DeferredToolCatalog with stable hash

* feat(tool-search): add build_deferred_tool_setup + Command-writing tool_search

* refactor(tool-search): replace deferred-tool ContextVar with closures + graph state (#3272)

Build the deferred catalog + tool_search tool per agent from the policy-filtered
tool list (after skill allowed-tools), pass deferred_names + catalog_hash
explicitly to DeferredToolFilterMiddleware and the prompt, and record promotions
in ThreadState.promoted (scoped by catalog_hash) via a Command-returning
tool_search. Removes DeferredToolRegistry and the _registry_var ContextVar so
deferral no longer depends on build/execute sharing an async context. MCP tools
are tagged with metadata[deerflow_mcp]; client.py assembles deferral the same way.

Catalog is built AFTER tool-policy filtering (no policy-excluded tool can leak via
tool_search) and assembly is fail-closed. Migrate tests off the deleted registry
APIs; delete the obsolete ContextVar-based #2884 regression (re-covered by
state-based tests in a follow-up).

* test(tool-search): lock tool_search promotion into next model turn via graph state

* test(tool-search): cross-context, policy-leak, fail-closed, #2884 isolation regressions

* test(tool-search): align real-LLM e2e with closure-based deferred setup

* docs: update DeferredToolFilterMiddleware description for closure+state design

* style(tests): drop unused import in test_deferred_setup (ruff)

* test(tool-search): harden merge_promoted + replace tautological catalog test

From independent code review:
- merge_promoted: use existing.get("catalog_hash") so a forward-incompatible
  or externally-injected persisted promoted dict triggers a replace instead of
  a KeyError crash; add regression test for the malformed-existing case.
- test_deferred_catalog: replace the `== [] or True` tautology (a test that
  could never fail) with a deterministic invalid-regex->literal-fallback check
  (positive match on calc + negative empty match).
- DeferredToolCatalog: comment why frozen-without-slots is required for the
  cached_property hash/names fields (adding slots=True would break them).

* fix(tool-search): read tool_search.enabled from self._app_config in client

DeerFlowClient._ensure_agent called get_app_config() directly to read
tool_search.enabled, but the client already resolves and stores its config as
self._app_config at construction (and uses it everywhere else). The bare call
re-resolves config from disk at agent-build time, which raises FileNotFoundError
in environments without a config.yaml (CI) — test_client.py's fixture only
patches get_app_config during __init__, so the later call hit the real loader.
Use self._app_config, matching the rest of the client.

* test(tool-search): lock tool_search post-policy append ordering

tool_search is appended after skill-allowlist filtering, so the allowlist
can no longer deny it by name. Lock the intended contract: it only appears
when allowed MCP tools survive the filter, and its catalog (derived from the
already policy-filtered list) can never expose a denied tool. Addresses the
ordering observation from the Copilot review on #3342.
This commit is contained in:
AochenShen99
2026-06-02 22:43:22 +08:00
committed by GitHub
parent 74e3e80cf6
commit d9f4724950
17 changed files with 768 additions and 1267 deletions
@@ -7,7 +7,6 @@ from deerflow.config.app_config import AppConfig
from deerflow.reflection import resolve_variable
from deerflow.sandbox.security import is_host_bash_allowed
from deerflow.tools.builtins import ask_clarification_tool, present_file_tool, task_tool, view_image_tool
from deerflow.tools.builtins.tool_search import get_deferred_registry
from deerflow.tools.sync import make_sync_tool_wrapper
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
@@ -127,57 +126,13 @@ def get_available_tools(
if mcp_tools:
logger.info(f"Using {len(mcp_tools)} cached MCP tool(s)")
# When tool_search is enabled, register MCP tools in the
# deferred registry and add tool_search to builtin tools.
if config.tool_search.enabled:
from deerflow.tools.builtins.tool_search import DeferredToolRegistry, set_deferred_registry
from deerflow.tools.builtins.tool_search import tool_search as tool_search_tool
# Reuse the existing registry if one is already set for
# this async context. ``get_available_tools`` is
# re-entered whenever a subagent is spawned
# (``task_tool`` calls it to build the child agent's
# toolset), and previously we used to unconditionally
# rebuild the registry — wiping out the parent agent's
# tool_search promotions. The
# ``DeferredToolFilterMiddleware`` then re-hid those
# tools from subsequent model calls, leaving the agent
# able to see a tool's name but unable to invoke it
# (issue #2884). ``contextvars`` already gives us the
# lifetime semantics we want: a fresh request / graph
# run starts in a new asyncio task with the
# ContextVar at its default of ``None``, so reuse is
# only triggered for re-entrant calls inside one run.
#
# Intentionally NOT reconciling against the current
# ``mcp_tools`` snapshot. The MCP cache only refreshes
# on ``extensions_config.json`` mtime changes, which
# in practice happens between graph runs — not inside
# one. And even if a refresh did happen mid-run, the
# already-built lead agent's ``ToolNode`` still holds
# the *previous* tool set (LangGraph binds tools at
# graph construction time), so a brand-new MCP tool
# couldn't actually be invoked anyway. The
# ``DeferredToolRegistry`` doesn't retain the names
# of previously-promoted tools (``promote()`` drops
# the entry entirely), so re-syncing the registry
# against a fresh ``mcp_tools`` list would
# mis-classify those promotions as new tools and
# re-register them as deferred — exactly the bug
# this fix exists to prevent.
existing_registry = get_deferred_registry()
if existing_registry is None:
registry = DeferredToolRegistry()
for t in mcp_tools:
registry.register(t)
set_deferred_registry(registry)
logger.info(f"Tool search active: {len(mcp_tools)} tools deferred")
else:
mcp_tool_names = {t.name for t in mcp_tools}
still_deferred = len(existing_registry)
promoted_count = max(0, len(mcp_tool_names) - still_deferred)
logger.info(f"Tool search active (preserved promotions): {still_deferred} tools deferred, {promoted_count} already promoted")
builtin_tools.append(tool_search_tool)
# Tag MCP-sourced tools so deferred-tool assembly (done at
# the agent construction site, AFTER tool-policy filtering)
# can identify them. No ContextVar / registry is built here;
# the deferred catalog + tool_search tool are assembled per
# agent from the policy-filtered tool list.
for t in mcp_tools:
t.metadata = {**(t.metadata or {}), "deerflow_mcp": True}
except ImportError:
logger.warning("MCP module not available. Install 'langchain-mcp-adapters' package to enable MCP tools.")
except Exception as e: