Files
milvus/internal/rootcoord/ddl_callbacks_collection_function_test.go
5def5ced4a enhance: enforce function-field binding principle for function DDL (#51360)
## What

Enforce a function–field binding principle for function DDL (add / drop
/ alter function on an existing collection), so a function and its
output field stay coupled and already-stored vectors can never be
silently invalidated by DDL.

BM25 and MinHash follow the strict binding: add/drop only via the
unified `add_function_field` / `drop_function_field`, output field
always coupled. **TextEmbedding is a temporary carve-out** — its legacy
`AddCollectionFunction` / `DropCollectionFunction` paths are retained,
so attach-over-existing-field and detach are still possible for it,
because `add_function_field` embedding backfill is not yet implemented.
It will be folded into the unified path in a follow-up. So the "always
coupled" invariant currently holds for BM25/MinHash, not TextEmbedding.

## Changes

- **AlterCollectionSchema invariant**: reject standalone add-function (a
function must be added together with its new output field), reject
detaching a function without dropping its output field, and reject
function cascade (a new function's input being another function's
output).
- **Legacy RPCs**: `AddCollectionFunction` / `DropCollectionFunction`
are rejected for BM25/MinHash (must use `add_function_field` /
`drop_function_field`) and retained only for TextEmbedding (see
carve-out). `AlterCollectionFunction` is kept and gains the whitelist
below. In the alter and legacy-add paths, function field IDs are always
re-derived from field names (never trusted from the request), so a
request cannot inject an unrelated field ID that a later
`drop_function_field` would delete.
- **alter_function whitelist**: only connection/runtime params may
change (TextEmbedding: `url`, `credential`, `timeout_ms`,
`max_client_batch_size`, `region`, `location`, `projectid`, `user`);
BM25/MinHash have no alterable params. Function identity (type, name,
input/output fields) and output-shaping params (`dim`, `model_name`,
`endpoint` — the TEI model identity, `normalize`, `truncate*`, prompts,
...) are immutable. Params are normalized (keys lowercased, duplicate
keys rejected) so a crafted duplicate key cannot bypass the diff.
- **drop_function_field**: allow any output-producing function (dropping
needs no backfill), removing the previous BM25/MinHash-only restriction.

## Not in scope / follow-up

- Extending `add_function_field` to TextEmbedding (post-creation add
would require backfilling every existing row through the external
embedding model) — deferred; folding the TextEmbedding legacy paths into
the unified binding follows this.
- MinHash input-field analyzer immutability lives on a different DDL
path (`AlterCollectionField`); tracked as a separate follow-up.

## Breaking changes

- `DropCollectionFunction` on a **MinHash** function (detach — remove
the function but keep its output field) is no longer supported; use
`drop_function_field` instead (drops the function together with its
output field). If a released version supported MinHash detach, migrate
any such call to `drop_function_field`.

issue: #51348

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Signed-off-by: MrPresent-Han <chun.han@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: MrPresent-Han <chun.han@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-07-18 05:04:39 +08:00

436 lines
15 KiB
Go

// Licensed to the LF AI & Data foundation under one
// or more contributor license agreements. See the NOTICE file
// distributed with this work for additional information
// regarding copyright ownership. The ASF licenses this file
// to you under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the
// "License"); you may not use this file except in compliance
// with the License. You may obtain a copy of the License at
//
// http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
//
// Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
// distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
// WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
// See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
// limitations under the License.
package rootcoord
import (
"context"
"testing"
"github.com/bytedance/mockey"
"github.com/cockroachdb/errors"
"github.com/stretchr/testify/mock"
"github.com/stretchr/testify/suite"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus-proto/go-api/v3/commonpb"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus-proto/go-api/v3/milvuspb"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus-proto/go-api/v3/schemapb"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/internal/metastore/model"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/internal/mocks/streamingcoord/server/mock_broadcaster"
mockrootcoord "github.com/milvus-io/milvus/internal/rootcoord/mocks"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/pkg/v3/streaming/util/message"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/pkg/v3/streaming/util/types"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/pkg/v3/util/typeutil"
)
type DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite struct {
suite.Suite
core *Core
mockBroadcaster *mock_broadcaster.MockBroadcastAPI
}
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) SetupTest() {
suite.core = initStreamingSystemAndCore(suite.T())
suite.mockBroadcaster = mock_broadcaster.NewMockBroadcastAPI(suite.T())
}
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TearDownTest() {
suite.mockBroadcaster = nil
suite.core.Stop()
suite.core = nil
}
// Helper function to create a test collection
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) createTestCollection() *model.Collection {
return &model.Collection{
DBID: 1,
CollectionID: 100,
Name: "test_collection",
Description: "test collection",
AutoID: true,
Fields: []*model.Field{
{
FieldID: 101,
Name: "id",
IsPrimaryKey: true,
AutoID: true,
DataType: schemapb.DataType_Int64,
IsFunctionOutput: false,
},
{
FieldID: 102,
Name: "vector",
DataType: schemapb.DataType_FloatVector,
IsFunctionOutput: false,
},
{
FieldID: 103,
Name: "text_field",
DataType: schemapb.DataType_VarChar,
IsFunctionOutput: false,
},
{
FieldID: 104,
Name: "output_field",
DataType: schemapb.DataType_FloatVector,
IsFunctionOutput: true,
},
},
Functions: []*model.Function{
{
ID: 1001,
Name: "test_function",
Type: schemapb.FunctionType_TextEmbedding,
Description: "test function",
InputFieldIDs: []int64{103},
InputFieldNames: []string{"text_field"},
OutputFieldIDs: []int64{104},
OutputFieldNames: []string{"output_field"},
Params: []*commonpb.KeyValuePair{
{Key: "param1", Value: "value1"},
},
},
},
VirtualChannelNames: []string{"test_channel"},
EnableDynamicField: false,
Properties: []*commonpb.KeyValuePair{{Key: "key1", Value: "value1"}},
SchemaVersion: 1,
}
}
// Helper function to create a test function schema
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) createTestFunctionSchema() *schemapb.FunctionSchema {
return &schemapb.FunctionSchema{
Name: "new_function",
Type: schemapb.FunctionType_TextEmbedding,
Description: "new test function",
InputFieldNames: []string{"text_field"},
OutputFieldNames: []string{"vector"},
Params: []*commonpb.KeyValuePair{
{Key: "param1", Value: "value1"},
},
}
}
func TestDDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite(t *testing.T) {
suite.Run(t, new(DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite))
}
// Test callAlterCollection function
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestCallAlterCollection_Success() {
ctx := context.Background()
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
dbName := "test_db"
collectionName := "test_collection"
// Create a test core with proper meta setup
core := newTestCore(withHealthyCode())
mockMeta := mockrootcoord.NewIMetaTable(suite.T())
core.meta = mockMeta
// Mock meta calls for getCacheExpireForCollection
mockMeta.EXPECT().GetCollectionByName(mock.Anything, dbName, collectionName, typeutil.MaxTimestamp, mock.Anything).Return(coll, nil)
mockMeta.EXPECT().ListAliases(mock.Anything, dbName, collectionName, typeutil.MaxTimestamp).Return([]string{}, nil)
// Mock broadcaster
suite.mockBroadcaster.EXPECT().Broadcast(mock.Anything, mock.MatchedBy(func(msg message.BroadcastMutableMessage) bool {
// Verify the message structure
return msg != nil
})).Return(&types.BroadcastAppendResult{}, nil)
err := callAlterCollection(ctx, core, suite.mockBroadcaster, coll, coll, dbName, collectionName)
suite.NoError(err)
}
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestCallAlterCollection_GetCacheExpireFailed() {
ctx := context.Background()
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
dbName := "test_db"
collectionName := "test_collection"
// Create a test core with proper meta setup
core := newTestCore(withHealthyCode())
mockMeta := mockrootcoord.NewIMetaTable(suite.T())
core.meta = mockMeta
// Mock meta calls to return error
mockMeta.EXPECT().GetCollectionByName(mock.Anything, dbName, collectionName, typeutil.MaxTimestamp, mock.Anything).Return(nil, errors.New("cache expire error"))
err := callAlterCollection(ctx, core, suite.mockBroadcaster, coll, coll, dbName, collectionName)
suite.Error(err)
suite.Contains(err.Error(), "cache expire error")
}
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestCallAlterCollection_BroadcastFailed() {
ctx := context.Background()
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
dbName := "test_db"
collectionName := "test_collection"
// Create a test core with proper meta setup
core := newTestCore(withHealthyCode())
mockMeta := mockrootcoord.NewIMetaTable(suite.T())
core.meta = mockMeta
// Mock meta calls for getCacheExpireForCollection
mockMeta.EXPECT().GetCollectionByName(mock.Anything, dbName, collectionName, typeutil.MaxTimestamp, mock.Anything).Return(coll, nil)
mockMeta.EXPECT().ListAliases(mock.Anything, dbName, collectionName, typeutil.MaxTimestamp).Return([]string{}, nil)
// Mock broadcaster to return error
suite.mockBroadcaster.EXPECT().Broadcast(mock.Anything, mock.Anything).Return(nil, errors.New("broadcast error"))
err := callAlterCollection(ctx, core, suite.mockBroadcaster, coll, coll, dbName, collectionName)
suite.Error(err)
suite.Contains(err.Error(), "broadcast error")
}
// Test alterFunctionGenNewCollection function
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestAlterFunctionGenNewCollection_Success() {
ctx := context.Background()
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
// Create a function schema to alter existing function
fSchema := &schemapb.FunctionSchema{
Name: "test_function", // Same name as existing function
Type: schemapb.FunctionType_TextEmbedding,
Description: "updated test function",
InputFieldNames: []string{"text_field"},
OutputFieldNames: []string{"vector"}, // Different output field
}
err := alterFunctionGenNewCollection(ctx, fSchema, coll)
suite.NoError(err)
// Verify function ID is preserved
suite.Equal(int64(1001), fSchema.Id)
// Verify input field IDs are set
suite.Equal([]int64{103}, fSchema.InputFieldIds)
// Verify output field IDs are set
suite.Equal([]int64{102}, fSchema.OutputFieldIds)
// Verify old output field is no longer marked as function output
oldOutputField := coll.Fields[3] // output_field
suite.False(oldOutputField.IsFunctionOutput)
// Verify new output field is marked as function output
newOutputField := coll.Fields[1] // vector
suite.True(newOutputField.IsFunctionOutput)
// Verify function is added to collection
suite.Len(coll.Functions, 1) // Original + new
}
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestAlterFunctionGenNewCollection_DiscardsClientFieldIds() {
ctx := context.Background()
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
// Client injects bogus field IDs (output_field_ids points at the unrelated
// "vector" field 102). Only the name-resolved IDs must persist, else a later
// drop_function_field would delete field 102.
fSchema := &schemapb.FunctionSchema{
Name: "test_function",
Type: schemapb.FunctionType_TextEmbedding,
InputFieldNames: []string{"text_field"},
InputFieldIds: []int64{999},
OutputFieldNames: []string{"output_field"},
OutputFieldIds: []int64{102},
}
err := alterFunctionGenNewCollection(ctx, fSchema, coll)
suite.NoError(err)
suite.Equal([]int64{103}, fSchema.InputFieldIds) // text_field only, 999 discarded
suite.Equal([]int64{104}, fSchema.OutputFieldIds) // output_field only, 102 discarded
}
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestAlterFunctionGenNewCollection_FunctionNotExists() {
ctx := context.Background()
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
fSchema := &schemapb.FunctionSchema{
Name: "non_existent_function",
}
err := alterFunctionGenNewCollection(ctx, fSchema, coll)
suite.Error(err)
suite.Contains(err.Error(), "function non_existent_function not exists")
}
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestAlterFunctionGenNewCollection_InputFieldNotExists() {
ctx := context.Background()
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
fSchema := &schemapb.FunctionSchema{
Name: "test_function",
InputFieldNames: []string{"non_existent_field"},
}
err := alterFunctionGenNewCollection(ctx, fSchema, coll)
suite.Error(err)
suite.Contains(err.Error(), "function's input field non_existent_field not exists")
}
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestAlterFunctionGenNewCollection_OutputFieldNotExists() {
ctx := context.Background()
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
fSchema := &schemapb.FunctionSchema{
Name: "test_function",
InputFieldNames: []string{"text_field"},
OutputFieldNames: []string{"non_existent_field"},
}
err := alterFunctionGenNewCollection(ctx, fSchema, coll)
suite.Error(err)
suite.Contains(err.Error(), "function's output field non_existent_field not exists")
}
// Test edge cases and error conditions
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestAlterFunctionGenNewCollection_OldOutputFieldNotExists() {
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
// Modify the existing function to have a non-existent output field
coll.Functions[0].OutputFieldNames = []string{"non_existent_output"}
fSchema := &schemapb.FunctionSchema{
Name: "test_function",
InputFieldNames: []string{"text_field"},
OutputFieldNames: []string{"vector"},
}
err := alterFunctionGenNewCollection(context.Background(), fSchema, coll)
suite.Error(err)
suite.Contains(err.Error(), "old version function's output field non_existent_output not exists")
}
// Test with empty collections and functions
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestAlterFunctionGenNewCollection_EmptyCollection() {
// Create collection with no functions
coll := &model.Collection{
Fields: []*model.Field{},
Functions: []*model.Function{},
}
fSchema := &schemapb.FunctionSchema{
Name: "test_function",
}
err := alterFunctionGenNewCollection(context.Background(), fSchema, coll)
suite.Error(err)
suite.Contains(err.Error(), "function test_function not exists")
}
// Test max function ID calculation
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestAddFunction_NextFunctionIDCalculation() {
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
// Add more functions to test max ID calculation
coll.Functions = append(coll.Functions, &model.Function{
ID: 2000,
Name: "function2",
})
coll.Functions = append(coll.Functions, &model.Function{
ID: 1500,
Name: "function3",
})
nextFunctionID := int64(StartOfUserFunctionID)
for _, f := range coll.Functions {
nextFunctionID = max(nextFunctionID, f.ID+1)
}
suite.Equal(int64(2001), nextFunctionID)
}
// Test broadcastAlterCollectionForAlterFunction
func (suite *DDLCallbacksCollectionFunctionTestSuite) TestBroadcastAlterCollectionForAlterFunction() {
suite.Run("success", func() {
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
mockMeta := mockrootcoord.NewIMetaTable(suite.T())
mockMeta.EXPECT().GetCollectionByName(mock.Anything, "test_db", "test_collection", typeutil.MaxTimestamp, mock.Anything).Return(coll, nil)
suite.core.meta = mockMeta
req := &milvuspb.AlterCollectionFunctionRequest{
DbName: "test_db",
CollectionName: "test_collection",
FunctionSchema: &schemapb.FunctionSchema{
Name: "test_function",
Type: schemapb.FunctionType_TextEmbedding,
InputFieldNames: []string{"text_field"},
OutputFieldNames: []string{"output_field"},
// identity unchanged; only a whitelisted connection param ("url") is altered
Params: []*commonpb.KeyValuePair{
{Key: "param1", Value: "value1"},
{Key: "url", Value: "http://new-endpoint"},
},
},
}
mocker := mockey.Mock(callAlterCollection).Return(nil).Build()
defer mocker.UnPatch()
err := suite.core.broadcastAlterCollectionForAlterFunction(context.Background(), req)
suite.NoError(err)
})
suite.Run("altering non-whitelisted param rejected", func() {
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
mockMeta := mockrootcoord.NewIMetaTable(suite.T())
mockMeta.EXPECT().GetCollectionByName(mock.Anything, "test_db", "test_collection", typeutil.MaxTimestamp, mock.Anything).Return(coll, nil)
suite.core.meta = mockMeta
req := &milvuspb.AlterCollectionFunctionRequest{
DbName: "test_db",
CollectionName: "test_collection",
FunctionSchema: &schemapb.FunctionSchema{
Name: "test_function",
Type: schemapb.FunctionType_TextEmbedding,
InputFieldNames: []string{"text_field"},
OutputFieldNames: []string{"output_field"},
Params: []*commonpb.KeyValuePair{
{Key: "param1", Value: "changed"},
},
},
}
err := suite.core.broadcastAlterCollectionForAlterFunction(context.Background(), req)
suite.ErrorContains(err, "cannot be altered")
})
suite.Run("external collection rejected", func() {
coll := suite.createTestCollection()
coll.Fields[2].ExternalField = "text_col"
mockMeta := mockrootcoord.NewIMetaTable(suite.T())
mockMeta.EXPECT().GetCollectionByName(mock.Anything, "test_db", "test_collection", typeutil.MaxTimestamp, mock.Anything).Return(coll, nil)
suite.core.meta = mockMeta
req := &milvuspb.AlterCollectionFunctionRequest{
DbName: "test_db",
CollectionName: "test_collection",
FunctionSchema: &schemapb.FunctionSchema{
Name: "test_function",
Type: schemapb.FunctionType_TextEmbedding,
InputFieldNames: []string{"text_field"},
OutputFieldNames: []string{"output_field"},
},
}
err := suite.core.broadcastAlterCollectionForAlterFunction(context.Background(), req)
suite.ErrorContains(err, externalCollectionFunctionMutationUnsupportedMsg)
})
}