Files
milvus/internal/datacoord/services_commit_backfill.go
T
e2787d3981 enhance: standardize error handling on merr + Sys/Input classification (#50221)
issue: #47420

## What this PR does

Project-wide migration of raw `fmt.Errorf` / `errors.New` in function
bodies onto
the `merr` framework, plus the Sys-vs-Input error classification and the
machinery it drives (retriability, fine-grained metrics, segcore
unification),
plus the convention docs and a linter that keeps it from regressing.

Scope: storage, proxy, coordinators (root/data/query), query node, data
node,
`pkg/util` & `internal/util`, expression parser, message queue,
streaming, and
misc packages. Bare raw-error usages went from ~3000 to a ~340 allowlist
(package-level sentinels / build-tag / test sites).

---

## How to review this PR

It is large but the vast majority is mechanical. Changes fall into three
tiers;
spend review budget on Part 2 and Part 3.

### Part 1 — Mechanical standardization (low risk, verify by rule)

Each converted call follows one of a small fixed set of rules. To
review, check
that each site obeys the matching rule rather than reading every line:

| Pattern | Rule |
|---|---|
| `fmt.Errorf("...")` originating a new error | →
`merr.WrapErrXxxMsg("...")` with a code matching the failure's meaning |
| Adding context to an existing typed error | → `merr.Wrap(err, "...")`
/ `merr.Wrapf(...)` — **preserves** the inner code (never `WrapErr*Err`,
which overwrites it) |
| Errors inside the streaming subsystem | → `status.New*` factories
(StreamingError), **not** merr — this is the component-internal dialect
(see `docs/dev/error_handling_guide.md`) |
| Low-level / control-flow signal caught by `errors.Is` | → kept as a
package-level `errors.New` sentinel (lowercase, same-package) |

Conventions are documented in `docs/dev/error_handling_guide.md`
(how-to) and
`docs/dev/error_sentinel_convention.md` (rules + audit). A
`gocritic`/`ruleguard`
rule (`rawmerrerror`, in `rules.go`) enforces "no raw `return
errors.New/fmt.Errorf`"
under `make verifiers`.

### Part 2 — Behavior changes (review these closely)

These are the sites where the wire contract or runtime behavior changes,
not just
the source text. Listed by category; representative locations given,
full set in
the diff.

**A. gRPC wire-code shifts: `UnexpectedError(1)/Code 65535` → typed
code.**
Where a handler previously returned a raw error (collapsed to
`Code=65535` on the
wire), it now returns a typed merr, so the client sees a real code. The
most
common shift is to `IllegalArgument(5)/Code 1100` (ParameterInvalid).
Touch
points include datanode task handlers (CreateTask/Query/Drop), proxy
Upsert,
querynode GetMetrics, datacoord CreateIndex, httpserver query-response
builder,
and typeutil schema validation. One code refinement: an index-param
validation
moved `1100` → `1101` (ParameterMissing). **Client/SDK assertions and
any code
that switched on `Code=65535` for these paths must be re-checked** (the
go_client
e2e assertions were already aligned in this PR).

**B. Prometheus `status` label contract change (externally visible).**
The proxy metric's coarse `fail` / `rejected` values are split into
`fail_input` / `fail_system` and `rejected_user` / `rejected_system` (in
`requestutil.ParseMetricLabel`; auth/privilege rejections count as
`rejected_user`), so dashboards can attribute a failure to caller vs
operator.
**Dashboards/alerts querying `status="fail"` must migrate to
`status=~"fail_.*"`, and `status="rejected"` to
`status=~"rejected_.*"`.** The
in-repo Grafana dashboard is already migrated; external dashboards built
on the
old values silently go empty after upgrade. This is the one change that
requires an ops-side migration.

**C. Retriability semantics.**
- C1: `merr.Status(err)` now forces `Retriable=false` when the error is
an
`InputError` — a malformed request can never succeed on blind retry, so
clients
never get the self-contradictory "your input is wrong but you may
retry".
- C2: `retry.Do` short-circuits an `InputError` (non-retriable) — **but
only when
  the caller did not pass a `RetryErr` predicate**. The check is an
`if c.isRetryErr != nil { ... } else if InputError { ... }` *mutually
exclusive*
branch (`pkg/util/retry/retry.go`): an explicit `RetryErr` takes
precedence and
bypasses the InputError abort. `retry.Handle` deliberately does **not**
apply
the InputError abort (its callers signal abort via `shouldRetry=false`).
Four
flusher startup callsites that must retry through transient "not ready"
errors
  were given explicit `RetryErr` escape hatches.

**D. segcore (C++→Go) error classification.**
A single shared Go-side table (`pkg/util/merr/segcore.go`) maps each
segcore code
to a merr sentinel + InputError/signal category, replacing scattered
hand-written
`if errorCode == ...` switches in the cgo wrappers. **Wire `Code` values
change
for every segcore pass-through error, not just the remapped ones.**
Named
sentinels remap (C++ `2003` → merr `2001`, `2033` → `2002`,
Folly/Knowhere codes
likewise); **all remaining pass-through codes (`2004`–`2043`, previously
surfaced to clients as raw C++ enum values) now serialize as `2000`**
(`ErrSegcore`), with the original C++ code preserved in the `Reason`
text
(`segcoreCode=...`); unknown/future codes collapse to `2000` as well
(pinned by
the `wire_code_projection` test). Transient segcore classes (object
storage /
file IO / OOM / mmap / FieldNotLoaded — 11 codes) now report
`Retriable=true`.
**Any client switching on raw segcore codes in the `2004`–`2043` range
must be
re-checked**; the in-Reason code remains available for diagnostics.
Signal
codes (PretendFinished / FollyCancel) are recognized centrally.
`errors.Is`-based
control flow on these (e.g. scheduler skip/retry) is preserved.

**E. InputError classification (25 sentinels + dynamic marks).**
25 sentinels in `errors.go` carry `WithErrorType(InputError)` (the
Collection /
ResourceGroup / Database families, `ErrIndexDuplicate`,
`ErrParameterInvalid`,
`ErrPrivilegeNotAuthenticated`, `ErrImportFailed`, `ErrQueryPlan`, ...),
plus dynamic
marks for the 8 segcore input codes (ExprInvalid, DimNotMatch,
MetricTypeInvalid, FieldIDInvalid, ...) and
`WrapErrAsInputError`. The widest blast radius is `ErrParameterInvalid`
(1100):
~2335 `WrapErrParameterInvalid*` callsites now classify as input /
non-retriable. Because of C1/C2 this changes retriability for
any path that returns these. **The audit to confirm no transient path
was
mis-marked is the single most important review item** (see Part 3). One
reverse
correction: storage field-stats parsing moved from `ErrParameterInvalid`
(input)
to `ErrDataIntegrity` — a corrupted stored stat is data corruption, not
user
input.

### Part 3 — Known risks & traps (called out proactively)

1. **`merr.Wrap` vs `WrapErr*Err` (code-masking).** `WrapErr*Err` builds
a
`wrappedMilvusError{sentinel: ErrServiceInternal}` whose `code()`
returns the
*outer* sentinel — it overwrites the inner typed code and hides the
`errors.Is`
chain. This is intentional (use it to *deliberately* downgrade), but it
was a
recurring conversion defect; the rule "add context with `merr.Wrap`,
downgrade
with `WrapErr*Err`" is enforced by convention and reviewed across the
diff.
2. **InputError × `retry.Do` blast radius.** Marking a sentinel
`InputError` makes
any `retry.Do(...)` without a `RetryErr` predicate stop retrying it.
Reviewers
should sanity-check that no transient use of the 19 newly-marked
sentinels
(especially `ErrParameterInvalid`) sits inside a retry loop that needed
to keep
   spinning. The known flusher cases were handled (see C2).
3. **The ~340 raw-error allowlist.** What remains as bare `errors.New`
is, by
design: package-level sentinels (caught by `errors.Is`), `//go:build
test`
sites, and out-of-band trees (`cmd/`, `tests/`, codegen, walimpls). The
linter
only bans the *direct-return* form; assignment-then-return escapes and
the full
no-exceptions ban are deferred to an AST-based linter (Tier 2,
documented).
4. **segcore C++ second step deferred.** This PR unifies classification
on the Go
side; splitting the dual-semantic C++ codes at the source is a
follow-up.

---

## Validation

- `make verifiers`: Go side clean (gofmt + static-check across modules,
including
  the new `rawmerrerror` rule with a 0-hit baseline repo-wide).
- `make test-go`: passing; the one real regression introduced (a
datanode
`invalid_task_type` assertion shifting `1` → `5` from a ParameterInvalid
  conversion) was fixed in-tree.
- go_client e2e CreateIndex assertions aligned to the new merr messages.

---------

Signed-off-by: zhenshan.cao <zhenshan.cao@zilliz.com>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-12 15:04:51 -07:00

385 lines
14 KiB
Go

// Licensed to the LF AI & Data foundation under one
// or more contributor license agreements. See the NOTICE file
// distributed with this work for additional information
// regarding copyright ownership. The ASF licenses this file
// to you under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the
// "License"); you may not use this file except in compliance
// with the License. You may obtain a copy of the License at
//
// http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
//
// Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
// distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
// WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
// See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
// limitations under the License.
package datacoord
import (
"context"
"sort"
"strconv"
"go.uber.org/zap"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus-proto/go-api/v3/commonpb"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus-proto/go-api/v3/milvuspb"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/internal/distributed/streaming"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/internal/json"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/internal/storage"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/internal/storagev2/packed"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/internal/streamingcoord/server/broadcaster/broadcast"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/pkg/v3/log"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/pkg/v3/proto/datapb"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/pkg/v3/proto/messagespb"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/pkg/v3/streaming/util/message"
"github.com/milvus-io/milvus/pkg/v3/util/merr"
)
// CommitBackfillResult fetches the Spark-produced BackfillResult JSON from
// object storage, classifies each segment entry (V2 vs V3), and dispatches the
// updates through the BatchUpdateManifest broadcast pipeline. V2 segments carry
// a column-group upsert; V3 segments carry a manifest version bump. The
// broadcaster ensures serialization against compaction and other DDL-like
// operations on the same collection.
func (s *Server) CommitBackfillResult(ctx context.Context, req *datapb.CommitBackfillResultRequest) (*datapb.CommitBackfillResultResponse, error) {
log := log.Ctx(ctx).With(zap.String("resultPath", req.GetResultPath()))
if err := merr.CheckHealthy(s.GetStateCode()); err != nil {
return &datapb.CommitBackfillResultResponse{Status: merr.Status(err)}, nil
}
result, err := s.loadBackfillResult(ctx, req.GetResultPath())
if err != nil {
log.Warn("CommitBackfillResult failed to load result JSON", zap.Error(err))
return &datapb.CommitBackfillResultResponse{Status: merr.Status(err)}, nil
}
items, statuses := s.classifyBackfillSegments(ctx, result)
total := int32(len(result.Segments))
// Nothing passed pre-validation: surface as top-level failure so the caller
// knows no broadcast happened. segment_statuses still carry per-segment
// diagnostics.
if len(items) == 0 {
return &datapb.CommitBackfillResultResponse{
Status: merr.Status(merr.WrapErrParameterInvalidMsg("no backfill segments passed pre-validation")),
TotalSegments: total,
SegmentStatuses: statuses,
FailedSegments: int32(len(statuses)),
}, nil
}
coll, err := s.broker.DescribeCollectionInternal(ctx, result.CollectionID)
if err != nil {
log.Warn("CommitBackfillResult failed to describe collection", zap.Error(err), zap.Int64("collectionID", result.CollectionID))
return &datapb.CommitBackfillResultResponse{Status: merr.Status(err)}, nil
}
// Split items across multiple broadcast messages so a single
// BatchUpdateManifestMessageBody never exceeds the broker's message size
// limit (Pulsar defaults to 5MiB). Each batch acquires its own broadcaster
// because broadcasterWithRK consumes its resource-key guards on the first
// Broadcast call and would panic on any subsequent call. Failure of one
// batch does not cancel subsequent batches; per-segment statuses reflect
// batch-level outcomes.
channels := []string{streaming.WAL().ControlChannel()}
var lastErr error
for start := 0; start < len(items); start += maxItemsPerBroadcast {
end := start + maxItemsPerBroadcast
if end > len(items) {
end = len(items)
}
batch := items[start:end]
if err := broadcastBackfillBatch(ctx, coll, result.CollectionID, channels, batch); err != nil {
log.Error("CommitBackfillResult broadcast batch failed",
zap.Error(err), zap.Int("batchStart", start), zap.Int("batchEnd", end))
lastErr = err
appendItemStatuses(&statuses, batch, false, err.Error())
continue
}
appendItemStatuses(&statuses, batch, true, "")
}
committed, failed := countStatuses(statuses)
log.Info("CommitBackfillResult broadcast completed",
zap.Int32("total", total),
zap.Int32("committed", committed),
zap.Int32("failed", failed))
// Top-level Success unless every broadcast failed -- partial failures are
// surfaced through per-segment statuses.
respStatus := merr.Success()
if committed == 0 && lastErr != nil {
respStatus = merr.Status(lastErr)
}
return &datapb.CommitBackfillResultResponse{
Status: respStatus,
TotalSegments: total,
CommittedSegments: committed,
FailedSegments: failed,
SegmentStatuses: sortStatuses(statuses),
}, nil
}
// maxItemsPerBroadcast caps the number of BatchUpdateManifestItem entries
// packed into a single broadcast message. With item payloads in the
// ~1-2KiB range for V2 column groups this stays well under Pulsar's default
// 5MiB maxMessageSize while keeping broadcast overhead low.
const maxItemsPerBroadcast = 512
// broadcastBackfillBatch acquires a fresh broadcaster bound to the
// collection's shared resource keys and issues exactly one broadcast for the
// given items. broadcasterWithRK nils out its lock guards on the first
// Broadcast call, so each batch needs its own broadcaster.
func broadcastBackfillBatch(
ctx context.Context,
coll *milvuspb.DescribeCollectionResponse,
collectionID int64,
channels []string,
items []*messagespb.BatchUpdateManifestItem,
) error {
broadcaster, err := broadcast.StartBroadcastWithResourceKeys(ctx,
message.NewSharedDBNameResourceKey(coll.GetDbName()),
message.NewSharedCollectionNameResourceKey(coll.GetDbName(), coll.GetCollectionName()),
)
if err != nil {
return err
}
defer broadcaster.Close()
_, err = broadcaster.Broadcast(ctx, message.NewBatchUpdateManifestMessageBuilderV2().
WithHeader(&message.BatchUpdateManifestMessageHeader{
CollectionId: collectionID,
}).
WithBody(&message.BatchUpdateManifestMessageBody{
Items: items,
}).
WithBroadcast(channels).
MustBuildBroadcast(),
)
return err
}
func appendItemStatuses(out *[]*datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus, batch []*messagespb.BatchUpdateManifestItem, ok bool, reason string) {
for _, it := range batch {
kind := "v3"
if it.GetV2ColumnGroups() != nil {
kind = "v2"
}
*out = append(*out, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: it.GetSegmentId(), Ok: ok, Kind: kind, Reason: reason,
})
}
}
// maxBackfillResultBytes caps the size of the result JSON read from object
// storage. The JSON is produced by an external system (Spark) and loaded into
// memory in one shot; a hard cap protects DataCoord from OOM on an oversized
// or malicious input. Real-world backfill results for collections in the
// hundreds of thousands of segments comfortably fit within this limit.
const maxBackfillResultBytes int64 = 64 * 1024 * 1024 // 64MiB
// loadBackfillResult reads and decodes the result JSON. The bucket is inferred
// from the configured chunk manager (if it exposes BucketName()) and used to
// reject s3a://<other-bucket>/... paths early.
func (s *Server) loadBackfillResult(ctx context.Context, rawPath string) (*BackfillResult, error) {
if rawPath == "" {
return nil, merr.WrapErrParameterMissingMsg("result_path is required")
}
bucket := bucketFromChunkManager(s.meta.chunkManager)
key, err := normalizeObjectKey(rawPath, bucket)
if err != nil {
return nil, merr.WrapErrParameterInvalidMsg(err.Error())
}
// Pre-check the object size so an untrusted external caller cannot force
// an unbounded in-memory Read.
size, err := s.meta.chunkManager.Size(ctx, key)
if err != nil {
return nil, err
}
if size > maxBackfillResultBytes {
return nil, merr.WrapErrParameterInvalidMsg(
"backfill result JSON " + strconv.FormatInt(size, 10) +
" bytes exceeds limit " + strconv.FormatInt(maxBackfillResultBytes, 10))
}
raw, err := s.meta.chunkManager.Read(ctx, key)
if err != nil {
return nil, err
}
var result BackfillResult
if err := json.Unmarshal(raw, &result); err != nil {
return nil, merr.WrapErrParameterInvalidMsg("failed to decode backfill result JSON: " + err.Error())
}
if !result.Success {
return nil, merr.WrapErrParameterInvalidMsg("backfill reported success=false; refusing to commit")
}
if result.CollectionID == 0 {
return nil, merr.WrapErrParameterInvalidMsg("backfill result missing collectionId")
}
if len(result.Segments) == 0 {
return nil, merr.WrapErrParameterInvalidMsg("backfill result has no segments")
}
return &result, nil
}
// classifyBackfillSegments validates each segment entry and constructs the
// broadcast items. Returns the items to broadcast plus per-segment failure
// statuses recorded during pre-validation (so callers can surface them to the
// client even when a segment never reached broadcast).
func (s *Server) classifyBackfillSegments(ctx context.Context, result *BackfillResult) ([]*messagespb.BatchUpdateManifestItem, []*datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus) {
bucket := bucketFromChunkManager(s.meta.chunkManager)
items := make([]*messagespb.BatchUpdateManifestItem, 0, len(result.Segments))
statuses := make([]*datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus, 0)
// Deterministic order so broadcast items & diagnostic output are stable.
segIDs := make([]string, 0, len(result.Segments))
for k := range result.Segments {
segIDs = append(segIDs, k)
}
sort.Strings(segIDs)
for _, segIDStr := range segIDs {
entry := result.Segments[segIDStr]
segID, perr := strconv.ParseInt(segIDStr, 10, 64)
if perr != nil {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: 0, Ok: false, Kind: "", Reason: "invalid segment id " + segIDStr,
})
continue
}
segInfo := s.meta.GetSegment(ctx, segID)
if segInfo == nil {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: segID, Ok: false, Kind: inferKind(&entry), Reason: "segment not found in meta",
})
continue
}
if segInfo.GetCollectionID() != result.CollectionID {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: segID, Ok: false, Kind: inferKind(&entry),
Reason: "segment does not belong to the result's collection",
})
continue
}
// Partition-scoped backfills set PartitionID to the target partition;
// collection-wide backfills leave it at 0 (no check). When non-zero,
// rejecting a mismatching segment prevents writing metadata against
// the wrong partition.
if result.PartitionID != 0 && segInfo.GetPartitionID() != result.PartitionID {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: segID, Ok: false, Kind: inferKind(&entry),
Reason: "segment does not belong to the result's partition",
})
continue
}
if segInfo.GetState() != commonpb.SegmentState_Flushed {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: segID, Ok: false, Kind: inferKind(&entry),
Reason: "segment state is not Flushed: " + segInfo.GetState().String(),
})
continue
}
if entry.IsV2() {
if segInfo.GetStorageVersion() != storage.StorageV2 {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: segID, Ok: false, Kind: "v2",
Reason: "segment storage version is not V2",
})
continue
}
groups, err := buildV2Groups(bucket, &entry)
if err != nil {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: segID, Ok: false, Kind: "v2", Reason: err.Error(),
})
continue
}
items = append(items, &messagespb.BatchUpdateManifestItem{
SegmentId: segID,
V2ColumnGroups: &messagespb.BatchUpdateManifestV2ColumnGroups{
ColumnGroups: groups,
},
})
} else {
// V3 path
if segInfo.GetStorageVersion() != storage.StorageV3 {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: segID, Ok: false, Kind: "v3",
Reason: "segment storage version is not V3",
})
continue
}
// UpdateManifestVersion no-ops when ManifestPath is empty. Reject
// here so the caller never sees a fake committed=true.
if segInfo.GetManifestPath() == "" {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: segID, Ok: false, Kind: "v3",
Reason: "segment has no existing manifest path",
})
continue
}
if entry.Version <= 0 {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: segID, Ok: false, Kind: "v3",
Reason: "missing or invalid manifest version",
})
continue
}
// Reject stale results (e.g. Spark retry) that would move the
// manifest pointer backwards. UpdateManifestVersion short-circuits
// only on equality, so enforcing strict monotonicity here is the
// correct guard against silent rollback.
_, currentVer, verErr := packed.UnmarshalManifestPath(segInfo.GetManifestPath())
if verErr != nil {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: segID, Ok: false, Kind: "v3",
Reason: "failed to parse current manifest path: " + verErr.Error(),
})
continue
}
if entry.Version <= currentVer {
statuses = append(statuses, &datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus{
SegmentId: segID, Ok: false, Kind: "v3",
Reason: "incoming manifest version " + strconv.FormatInt(entry.Version, 10) +
" is not greater than current " + strconv.FormatInt(currentVer, 10),
})
continue
}
items = append(items, &messagespb.BatchUpdateManifestItem{
SegmentId: segID,
ManifestVersion: entry.Version,
})
}
}
return items, statuses
}
func inferKind(entry *BackfillSegment) string {
if entry.IsV2() {
return "v2"
}
return "v3"
}
func countStatuses(statuses []*datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus) (committed, failed int32) {
for _, st := range statuses {
if st.GetOk() {
committed++
} else {
failed++
}
}
return
}
func sortStatuses(statuses []*datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus) []*datapb.CommitBackfillResultSegmentStatus {
sort.SliceStable(statuses, func(i, j int) bool {
return statuses[i].GetSegmentId() < statuses[j].GetSegmentId()
})
return statuses
}